Take it back to the store. They are very good at refunds.

I used to love the body wash. I used to use it as well. The stuff at Bath and Body Works isn't all that appealing to me anymore, and I haven't shopped there in quite some time. Thanks for the information . Very good post...and, sad, the proof that "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" applies to something you enjoyed.

Bill, you crack me up. You made up the Ferret Ear Wash, didn't you? I'm not going to google it; I'd rather believe that it's a flight of supreme imagination. I'm going to give you a tip: Trader Joe's Oatmeal Honey Soap. Good stuff, mild, and cheap. BTW, among those ingredients, was there any coconut, lime, or verbena at all?